“Nostalgia’s overrated.”

i know what you did last summer 2025

I KNOW WHAT YOU DID LAST SUMMER

2.5 Stars  2025/15/111m

“You get the ending you deserve.”

Director/Writer: Jennifer Kaytin Robinson / Writers: Sam Lansky, Leah McKendrick / Cast: Madelyn Cline, Chase Sui Wonders, Jonah Hauer-King, Tyriq Withers, Sarah Pigeon, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Freddie Prinze Jr., Billy Campbell, Gabbriette Bechtel, Austin Nichols, Joshua Orpin, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Brandy Norwood.

Laughter Lines: “The notes, the hook, it’s all sounding similar to ’97.”

Body Count: 9


Some sorta-spoilers.

Requels. They’re… a breed of their own, largely accurately covered by Mindy’s speech in Scream (2022), played out to varying degrees of success with the Blumhouse Halloween films (one good, one middling, one wretched), the Netflix Texas Chainsaw Massacre (largely maligned), and now a long-awaited third part to the Julie/Ray thread of I Know What You Did Last Summer.

Lois Duncan’s 1973 teen thriller about two young couples who accidentally ran over and killed a kid was adapted first into the 1997 slasher movie (spoiler: nobody in the book is murdered), followed up by the love/hate I Still Know What You Did Last Summer, rebooted for the DTV market in the hate/hate I’ll Always Know What You Did Last Summer, adapted again for Prime’s mostly-awful 2021 mini-series (which took the place of the never-to-be Mike Flanagan adap.) and now, 28 years after the first film, requelled.

i know what you did last summer 2025

This house has been built largely on unstable fan service foundations. References to ‘what happened in 1997’ do not stop coming, from random signs in the background, fitting character names, visits to the cemetery to see the headstones of the victims, right up to a shoehorned dream sequence where fucking Buffy herself, Sarah Michelle Gellar, appears as the ghost of Helen Shivers!! This is also after a podcaster bears a Helen Shivers t-shirt. A+ for all of this. They really couldn’t throw any more at it. But the rest…

After their engagement party in Southport, high-end couple Danica and Teddy take their will-they/won’t-they friends Milo and Ava and old high school pal Stevie up to Reaper’s Pass – the best place to watch the July 4th firework show. Dicking about in the road, a truck swerves, narrowly missing Teddy, but crashing through the barrier. It teeters on the cliff edge as the group try to save the occupant, but ultimately gravity wins out. They call the cops anonymously and high-tail it out of there.

i know what you did last summer 2025

One year later, Ava returns to Southport for Danica’s bridal shower for upcoming wedding to new fiancé, Wyatt, after having split from Teddy. During receipt of the gifts, she cracks a card bearing that loveable phrase ‘I know what you did last summer’ and Wyatt is soon after harpooned to death.

After a second murder that the local bigwigs (led by Teddy’s father) try to pass off as a suicide, a townhall meeting is crashed by Ray Bronson, who insists they should all take note of what happened last time, but they channel their collective Jaws personas to try and brush it aside. Ava, meanwhile, tracks down Julie, now teaching at a school not so far away, having divorced Ray for ‘not dealing with his trauma’.

i know what you did last summer 2025

Further attacks ensue, largely laying background characters to waste but eventually reaching the shores of our youthful cast, who suspect the local pastor when it transpires it was his truck that went over the cliff, having been stolen by the driver. Things culminate aboard a yacht with the final few members of the guilty group trying to evade a hooking, and the killer is revealed. However, based on previous scenes – plus clips from various trailers – we know it can’t end here.

I Know ’25 throws in another twist, which is a fairly brave one, but one also undermined by an earlier exchange, leaving a rather gaping plot hole large enough for Teddy’s luxury yacht to comfortably sail through. But stick around for the mid-credits scene where Karla appears for her cameo (not a spoiler given the cast roster above) as the film clamours to re-energise its sequel potential.

i know what you did last summer 2025 jennifer love hewitt freddie prinze jr

Remove Hewitt, Prinze, and the cameos and this is a nothing burger of a project, arguably as bad as I’ll Always Know in the ridiculousness stakes. The plates it spins depend so hard on coincidences that the jokes and gags are a necessary distraction, as it cannot be taken seriously. The production unities are passable, though it does feel like shooting it in New South Wales, Australia, was a money-saving decision.

Southport also really could do with an influx of qualified driving instructors.

Blurbs-of-interest: Chase Sui Wonders was in Bodies Bodies Bodies; Sarah Michelle Gellar was in Scream 2.