Back to blood beach

MUTILATOR 2
2023/83m
Director/Writer: Buddy Cooper / Cast: Terry Kiser, Ruth Martinez, Bill Hitchcock, Wyatt Easterling, Ryan James, Dan Grogan, Mark Francis, Carl J. Grasso, Carroll Herring, Loren Swan, Cody Renee Cameron, Chaney Morrow, Marco Reese Maldonado, Damian Maffei, Eva Hamilton.
Body Count: 11
I was never keen on 1984’s The Mutilator. It was a little too cheap and derivative for me, with my main memory being how long a scene dragged on of nothing more than a guy having a conversation with a closet door.
The film was somewhat notable for its gory denouements at the mercy of various tools and fishing implements, enough for this love letter outer-world sequel to come together almost forty years later, helmed by OG director Cooper (with script assistance from the Soska Sisters), and featuring roles for a couple of the actors who play themselves at a wrap party for a remake of the film.

Occurring on location at the very same Carolina beach house, when the uptight director is killed by a camera, the surviving crew muster to try and finish the film in time for the party, which is attended by actors Ruth Martinez, Bill Hitchcock, and Terry Kiser as the late Jack Chatham (who played the killer).
Meanwhile, horny Weinstein-esque producer Henry tries to seduce young female crew members, and a horror YouTuber scams his way into the party to record footage. But who has flipped and continues to kill off those associated with the film? Inventive practical-effect sayonaras this time include eyes plucked out by fishing hooks, swordfish impalings, and the return of that gnarly giant hook from that scene first time around.

Make no mistake, Mutilator 2 is a mess, with characters who just disappear from the film entirely, no real central figure to carry things, random skits inserted, and an unclear gag of an outcome. But I’m a sucker for this kind of ode to earlier work in this way, so I was never bored – just a bit confused here and there. (What was the scene with the lady in the chef’s hat??) If you’re not familiar with the original though, this will make precisely zero sense.
Blurbs-of-interest: Damian Maffei was also in The Strangers: Prey at Night and the 2021 re-do of Wrong Turn; Eva Hamilton was in Ruin Me; Terry Kiser can be seen in Mask Maker and as the evil Dr Crews in Friday the 13th Part VII.
