May the odds be never in your favour

fear street prom queen 2025

FEAR STREET: PROM QUEEN

2.5 Stars  2025/18/88m

“Winning just be the death of you.”

Director/Writer: Matt Palmer / Writers: Donald McLeary, R.L. Stine / Cast: India Fowler, Fina Strazza, Suzanna Son, Lili Taylor, Katherine Waterston, Chris Klein, David Iacono, Ella Rubin, Arana Greenblatt, Rebecca Ablack, Ilan O’Driscoll, Darrin Baker.

Body Count: 11


The 2021 Fear Street trilogy kinda surfed along amiably, with one great entry, one decent one, and one disappointing one (and not in that order), this 2025 single-item project perhaps wisely chooses to span just a single regular length film, with a far less expansive tale that’s a simple back-to-basics high school slasher pic.

In the summer of 1988, Shadyside High School’s senior prom looms and the race is on for the life-defining status of being crowned the prom queen. It’s strange how so few films focus on the prom king. Do the boys just not care? Anyway, if horror films have taught us nothing else, it’s that prom usually brings with it an axe wielding killer. Or a girl with telekinetic powers sparking off.

fear street prom queen posters

Four of the six PQ candidates are part of the same clique – known as the Wolf Pack – led by megabitch Tiffany Falconer, who delights in tormenting the girl across the street, fellow nominee Lori Granger, whose mother is rumoured to have murdered her father at her own prom years earlier. The last candidate is streetwise drug peddler Christie, who gives no fucks and just wants to laud any victory over Tiffany and her clones.

While Lori plans to attend with her horror-loving BFF Megan, a be’masked and be’macked killer shows up and begins trimming the list of candidates, along with their boyfriends and anybody else who gets in his way: Horny teens are sawn, electrocuted and, in one memorably LOLsome scene (albeit ripped right out of Tormented) relieved of their hands by paper-guillotine.

fear street prom queen 2025 rebecca ablack

Things unfold agreeably for around 65 minutes (look out for the hilarious dance off), until the killer is unmasked and Prom Queen unwisely piles on a series of additional revelations which fall strangely flat, robbing the audience of a scene they’d likely been waiting for in favour of the not so twisty twist. The weakness of the ending caps the movie off at the knees (along with one of the characters), resulting in a flaccid vehicle. A shame, as the preceding hour or so was at least decent.

On the plus side, the soundtrack bounces along with all your parents’ favourite 80s hits, Fowler makes for a likeable heroine, and Strazza serves nice post-Wendy energy as the nasty girl, but what impressed the most was one of the mean girls flipping sides and helping out Lori, but is then summarily killed off anyway. Too few slasher films allow for likeable characters to be offed. Heaven forbid we feel something.

fear street prom queen 2025

Essentially, it’s My Super Psycho Sweet 16 all over again, but with an annoying outcome. Will we ever get a perfect prom-based slasher pic?

Blurb-of-interest: Ella Rubin was the lead in Until Dawn.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.